Below, three checkboxes are provided in the source code in different ways. Implicitly once without and once with a for attribute. Implicitly means that the label element wraps the checkbox element in the source code. In the explicit variant, the label element is placed after the checkbox element (it does not wrap it) and has a for attribute.
Go directly to the results
For a long time, common experience was that some older screen reader/browser combinations needed the for attribute in the implicit version. It was also common experience that the voice control software Dragon could not reliably handle the implicit variants without having to use numbers/grids.
For a current reason, I wanted to test today whether this is still the case. I was surprised to find that the latest version of Dragon now also handles implicit labels properly. An experienced voice control user has also confirmed this to me.
The prerequisite is that Dragon is installed properly and that Windows is fully up to date, as a recent Windows update caused various problems. You should fix that problem if you want to retest the situation yourself.
Implicitly
Explicitly
Results
(As of October 5th, 2026:)
All three variants worked with the following assistive technologies.
- NVDA screen reader, version 2026.2, with Chrome 154.0.x on Windows
- TalkBack screen reader with Chrome 154.0.x on Android 16
- Voice Control with Safari on iPhone 16 and iOS 27.0
- Nuance Dragon Professional 16 with Edge on Windows
I was surprised to find that Dragon now handles implicit labels directly (without having to rely on numbers or grids). To my knowledge, this hadn’t been the case for a long time.